Living and breathing in the Second City
The ballyhoo over the Supreme Court’s recent decision that declared Washington DC’s handgun ban unconstitutional, and therefore implied the same for Chicago, didn’t last through the holiday. Unfortunately, neither did five poor souls who fell victim to gun violence in downtown Chicago during the long weekend.
“Why should our streets be open to someone carrying a gun?” Daley remarked after the Supreme Court handed down the ruling. “Do [people] have a right to carry a gun on the CTA?” Daley’s theatric rant blamed the rich and the powerful for protecting themselves but not the poor. “Those who are rich always feel safe … those who are in power always feel safe.”
But after the violence this past weekend, Daley must face a stubborn fact: handgun bans don’t actually prevent people from committing violence with hand guns. Handguns are illegal in Chicago, and yet on July 4th, four people were shot by handguns as they walked home from the fireworks display in Grant Park. Moreover, it is entirely likely these hand guns were brought to the fireworks show on CTA transportation. Fitting isn’t it.
This is not unusual, in fact. Every day, innocent people in Chicago are killed by hand guns despite the ban. Chicago reported 442 homicides in 2007, according to Wikipedia. And yet, Daley would have us believe the law is keeping the “poor” people safe.
Of course, Daley could step up enforcement. He could put an officer armed with an assault rifle on every corner of the city. But still there would likely be some incidence of illegal gun violence. He simply doesn’t have the power to control human behavior, no matter how much prohibition is enforced. Banning anything only drives it under ground.
We certainly should not be irresponsible with guns. But we shouldn’t run roughshod over our constitutional rights in support of laws that embolden politicians but don’t do much for public safety.
Daley would do better to focus on things that are within his control, like the safety issues on the CTA.
The fog comes
on little cat feet.
It sits looking
over harbor and city
on silent haunches
and then moves on.
-Carl Sandburg
Michael Tams
July 10th, 2008 at 3:06 pm
Mike,
Great column. That human nature is lost on such a wide swath of the population (also known as: Democrats) never fails to amaze me. Would I be less or more likely to cut off someone in traffic if I thought there was a chance that they could pull out a gun and shoot? While this is an absurd analogy (I am a fantastic driver), it illustrates that we’re unlikely (less likely) to transgress if we are unsure about the certainty of consequences. If mere thoughtlessness can be so curbed, how much so then the deliberate plans of a criminal? If anyone you walk up to may be armed, how likely are you to take a chance on mugging someone when there are generous concealed carry laws? If there are hand gun bans?
Logic, reason, and an understanding of human nature; these should be prerequisites in our representatives.
MT
cassius king
July 10th, 2008 at 10:00 pm
Daley always blames problems on something or some one else. It is his administration to blame for the messes we are in. Two decades of his crony capitalism has bankrupted the city financially, socially and morally. The education system is worse now than when he entered office despite attempted manipulation of statistics leading our kids who are Smart to see there’s no future here for them. The CTA’s costs per ride are more than sharing a taxi. Sales taxes are the highest in the nation bleeding the life from the poor. The police force is a mess. Employers are leaving the city because of high costs while there are few businesses to succeed to their places because of Chicago’s well deserved reputation for the city shaking businesses down. Electric, gas and gasoline prices are the highest in the nation. Corruption in city government takes it model from the top. There are thousands of city owned vacant lots in the neighborhoods off the tax roles which should be just auctioned to the highest bidder. City assets are sold off for low prices relative to revenue bonds to raise cash creating an invisible tax hike on our citizenry. Lawyers and Wall Street firms hire political relatives to gain untoward fees.
RISE UP my brothers and sisters. Throw off this yoke.